"N-No!"
"Huh? Jess!?"
"T-Today's no good... I'm dirty down there!"
It seemed she misunderstood me leaning closer as an attempt to go down on her. She clamped her thighs shut, hiding her crotch with both hands in resistance.
I hadn't planned on it, but her saying that made me want to. Honestly, if it's Jessica's pussy, I wouldn't mind even as-is.
"No good? I wouldn't mind if it's yours, Jess."
"E-Ethan, you pervert!! Absolutely not!"
"Absolutely?"
"Yes, absolutely!! I-If you really... want to, then let me shower first..."
"...Got it. I won't do it with my mouth today."
"R-Really? I'm trusting you, okay...?"
"You can trust me on that..."
I gave up on eating her out and instead focused on her beautiful breasts. I took her nipple into my mouth again while sneaking a hand down to her crotch.
"Ahh... Nngh, ahh!"
Jessica's pussy was already wet. As I sucked on her stiff, pointed nipple, I teased her slippery slit with my fingers.
"Ahhn! Ethan... It feels so good..."
"Mmm, slurp... lick..."
I played with her damp entrance, using her arousal to slickly rub her clit. Her moans grew even higher-pitched, driving me to move my fingers and mouth with reckless abandon.
"Ahh! M-More... Ahhn!"
I swirled my tongue around her erect nipple while persistently fondling her now-dripping pussy. The lust magic had completely overwhelmed her senses, sending her racing toward climax.
"Y-Yes! I-I'm... gonna cum!"
"Lick... Go ahead. Cum for me?"
"Ahh! N-No! I-I'm gonna... cum!"
"So cute... Mmm, suck... slurp~"
"T-That's it! I'm cumming!! I'm—!! Aaahhh!!! ♡"
She writhed, her glistening body arching as she gripped the sheets and came. While worshipping her swollen clit and nipples, I felt my own limit approaching.
I sat up, pulling off my underwear, now stained with pre-cum. My fully erect cock stood proudly as I walked over to my bag.
I rummaged through it, pulling out a leftover condom from Christmas. After rolling it onto my throbbing length, all that was left was to push inside.
I returned to Jessica, whose chest still heaved with heavy breaths. I lifted her long legs—nearly half my height—and positioned myself between them.
Gripping my shaft, I lined it up with her still-innocent-looking entrance. Now, the missionary position was ready.
"...Ah, Ethan..."
By then, she had recovered from her climax, looking up at me with damp eyes. Her uneasy expression only stoked my desire further.
"I-I'm going in, okay?"
"B-Be gentle... Please."
"O-Of course..."
I wasn't sure how forceful I should be while pretending to be inexperienced. For now, I respected her request and decided to take it slow.
"Okay... here I go?"
"...U-Unn... Guh, ughh..."
Even on the second time, she still seemed to be in pain, her face twisted in discomfort. Hearing her strained whimpers while feeling this good made me feel a little guilty.
Still, my tip pressed forward, invading deeper into her tight passage. Though her slick juices made it easier, it wasn't enough to erase the pain entirely.
"Ngh... i-it hurts... ahh!!"
I took my time, slowly pushing until I reached the deepest part. Then, I paused to check on her.
Sweat covered her body from the pain, her muscles tense. To ease her suffering, I cast a weak pain-reduction spell, just like on Christmas.
"Ugh... nngh, haah..."
It seemed to help a little, but she was still in discomfort. That said, her tightness was driving me wild, and I couldn't hold back anymore.
"I'm moving."
"Nngh... s-slowly, okay...?"
"Y-Yeah. I'll try."
I began thrusting gently, careful not to overwhelm her. Even though the condom kept me from direct contact, the pleasure was still overwhelming.
"H-How's this?"
"I-It hurts, but... I can... handle it..."
"O-Okay. Then, I'll make you cum fast."
Between the mental high of being inside Jessica and her tightness gripping me, I was on the verge of exploding. I could've held back, but playing the inexperienced role, I let my desires take over.
"Ahh... I-I'm gonna cum!"
"Ugh... E-Ethan..."
"I-I'm coming! I'm—! Cumming!!"
"Guh, ughh... ahh!"
"I-I love you!! Jess!! Uuugh!!"
At the end, I couldn't help but speed up, unleashing a thick load into the condom. As I pulled out, she winced, still in pain from even that movement.
I disposed of the condom, then glanced at my still-hard cock. I figured I'd ask for round two.
"...Can we go again?"
"A-Again...? ...I-I think... twice in a row is too much..."
"...No good?"
"Ugh... W-Well, it's not my fault Ethan's... is too big!"
Suddenly, Jessica started lecturing me about my size. I had wondered if I'd overdone it with the enlargement magic.
"I looked it up on my phone, and... y-you're way bigger than average!!"
"S-Sorry... Wait, you looked it up?"
"Ah... W-Well, it's not your fault you're big..."
I couldn't exactly say, "Actually, I used magic to make it bigger!" An awkward silence fell between us.
But knowing that even a proper, refined beauty like Jessica would look up such things made her feel more relatable. Underneath that perfect Yamato Nadeshiko exterior, she was still a curious high school girl.
"..."
"E-Ethan!?"
"Y-Yes!?"
She'd been stealing glances at my still-hard cock, now leaking pre-cum, before suddenly raising her voice. Flustered, she averted her gaze.
"W-Well... n-no sex, but..."
"N-No sex, but...?"
"...M-Maybe... with my mouth..."
"With your mouth... You mean a blowjob!?"
"Idiot! Don't say it!"
At Christmas, it was a handjob—but now, for New Year's, we were leveling up to a blowjob. My cock twitched at the thought of those soft, pillowy lips wrapped around me.
Just imagining her delicate mouth servicing me sent my excitement through the roof. Unable to resist, I gripped my shaft and moved closer.
"T-Then, please—"
"...Hm? What's wrong?"
"N-Nothing, just..."
Then it hit me—I hadn't cleaned up down there. Was it really okay to put that in Jessica's mouth?
I decided to wash up first. It wouldn't take long, and she wouldn't change her mind in that time.
"...I'll go wash real quick."
"Ah, wash?"
"Same as you earlier. I can't just... ask you to do it like this."
"Nn... O-Okay, I'll wait..."
"It won't take long."
I grabbed a towel from my bag and left the love nest. The winter hallway was brutally cold for a naked body, and the bathroom would be even worse.
"Ugh... So cold...!"
I hurried to the bathroom, gritting my teeth against the chill as I prepped the shower for warm water.
"If it were warmer, we could've gone together..."
I briefly considered sharing the cramped tub, but filling it would take too long. Bathing together, washing each other... I'd save that for another time.
Once the shower was ready, I started cleaning my cock. Mindful of Jessica waiting, I worked quickly but thoroughly.